The Village (2004) — The emperor’s new-old clothes

“We have agreed never to go back. Never.”

Justin’s rating: Red is the color of my love for you

Justin’s review: At this point in my life, I’m no closer to cracking the bizarre enigma that is M. Night Shyamalan and his eccentric filmography. From The Sixth Sense to Unbreakable to Signs, we were convinced in the early 2000s that this man was a mind-blowing genius — and we ignored all the signs (sorry) to the contrary. But it was in The Village where his legion of fans suspected that he was the director equivalent of a quack and turned on him — perhaps too harshly.

I’ve only once before seen The Village, back in 2004 in the theater, and even over two decades later, I can remember being greatly conflicted at that time. This is where we started to see Shyamalan’s brilliant and faulty dichotomy exposed more clearly than before. He mixed the best and worst traits of a filmmaker into a highly publicized and expensive end product, and people started to notice that this emperor might not be wearing clothes all the time.

The Village proved to be a backfire because it is — at its core — a huge misdirect that’s hoping you’ll be more pleased by the reveal than upset. A lot of people were in the latter category, and their wrath was vocal and plentiful. That marked the moment when audience members and critics alike stopped mindlessly fawning over Shyamalan and started genuinely critiquing his works. That’s when we noticed how absolutely awful and unnatural his dialogue and characterization tended to be. That’s also when we noticed that a lot of these films’ internal logic crumbled under intense scrutiny.

We are invited to join the lives of an isolated, Amish-like village that seems to live in a state of constant apprehension. There’s peace here, yes, but nobody is allowed beyond the treeline, and sentries watch diligently every night. Many questions emerge as we get to know the inhabitants: What is out in the woods? What is that strange noise that rolls in every now and then? Why is the color red — even in flowers — forbidden? And who gave yet more acting work to the wooden post known as William Hurt?

As an illness strikes the village, there is a desire from some, namely perceptive Lucius (Joaquin Phoenix) and completely blind Ivy (Bryce Dallas Howard), to venture out beyond the woods to seek much-needed medicine from other towns. But the elders are staunchly against this, even as a dangerous internal threat starts to emerge.

Upon a rewatch, I can’t bring myself to wholesale condemn The Village the way many have. There’s too much good here to do that. For starters, it’s gorgeously filmed with many memorable shots, and the overall atmosphere is quite tense and foreboding. The soundtrack is astonishing. And this film does a great job conveying the terror of the unknown and the oppression of the woods back in a time when we could only see as far as a torch would light.

Being invited into the life of the village keeps the first half far more interesting than it has any right to be. I even like the story and where it goes, although I have to say that this is a one-trick pony. You can only ever watch The Village once before its reveal forever changes how you view it upon subsequent viewings, and there’s something special in that first time that is missed afterward.

But it’s definitely not perfect. For this storyline to work, a whole lot has to be unsaid and scenes have to be constructed in such a way not to give away it all. It also does make it more difficult to enjoy as a story upon rewatches, and if you know, you know.

Rewatches also emphasize how badly the dialogue tumbles and flops out of mouths. Around this time we were mocking Attack of the Clones for its awful romantic speeches, but let me tell you, The Village is like that romantic speech spread over two hours of such awkward declarations.

There are so many more interesting places this movie could’ve gone — supernatural, fairy tale, or fantasy come to mind — and it would’ve been so much better for it. Instead, Shyamalan elects for a fairly mundane reveal and then doesn’t do enough to fortify that decision. Seriously, the more you think about this, the more it utterly falls apart, and you’re left wondering if the director/writer really thought this through.

Roger Ebert called The Village a “shaggy dog story,” and I think that’s perhaps the most succinct and truthful summary of this movie. Its failure to live up to its promise is maddening, and I can understand the backlash, even if I don’t feel riled up enough to join in it after so long. I’ll say that this is worth at least one watch if you want something a little odd, a little fantastical, and a little intriguing. Just don’t set your hopes too high that this is the second coming of The Sixth Sense.

Intermission!

  • The tombstone with the year 1897
  • The red flower picked
  • Eww skinned cat
  • According to these elders, coyotes are excellent skinners?
  • “Do not tell anyone else of your burstings until you have spoken with the young man.”
  • She can see hazy colors of some people? OK then.
  • “There are secrets in every corner of this village.”
  • “You are fearless in a way that I shall never know.”
  • “I do long to do boy things.”
  • The fact that Judy Greer’s character is named “Kitty” made me think that this is a very roundabout Arrested Development crossover.
  • You’d think this village would have better medical facilities
  • “No good can come without sacrifice.”
  • They don’t have money? That raises more questions, just stack them on the pile over there.
  • “Do your very best not to scream.”
  • “If it ends, it ends.”
  • Every guard shack is stocked with that much meds? For animal attacks?

One comment

Leave a Reply